Skip to content

Debt collection agency or software: which to choose

A practical comparison for companies with many receivables: how an agency and software work, what they cost and when each one fits.

How the two models work

A collection agency takes over accounts and works them on the creditor's behalf, usually for a commission on what it recovers. In Italy, collecting on behalf of third parties requires the licence set out in art. 115 of the TULPS.

Debt collection software is a tool you use: it contacts debtors, negotiates and records every message, while the receivable stays managed by your company.

The comparison at a glance

  • Cost: commission on recoveries for an agency; licence or subscription, independent of the outcome, for software.
  • Control: with an agency you hand over tone and timing; with software you decide them.
  • Customer relationship: contact stays in your company's name with software, a third party's with an agency.
  • Speed: software starts from the first day of delay; agencies usually step in on older debts.
  • Complex cases: disputes and very old debts often need a lawyer or an agency.

When software fits

  • Many small to mid-size accounts, where commission weighs heavily.
  • Relationships to protect, such as utilities, subscriptions and consumer credit.
  • The need to act early, in the first days of delay.
  • The need for a single history and recovery data.

When an agency or lawyer fits

  • High-value debts or debtors who dispute the claim.
  • Very old accounts that need asset searches or legal action.
  • Companies that do not want to handle any stage in-house.

They can work together

They are not mutually exclusive. Many companies use software for the early stage and pass only unresolved cases to lawyers or agencies, so commission is paid only on the hard ones.

Check scope of activity and each party's responsibilities with your adviser.

Want to see how the software works? See JustSolve debt collection software with AI agents.See the solution

Agency and software questions

Can't find the answer you need? Write to us

Ready to supercharge your credit team?

Tell us how you handle unpaid invoices and we’ll show you where JustSolve can help.